At the Barrio Maulap plaza, several residents disdain Teresa (Judy Ann Santos)’s presence during a meeting called by Domeng (Simon Ibarra). But their ill feelings fade when Domeng announces that Teresa managed to retrieve their properties from the Rosales Group. The people then thank Teresa for her help and efforts.
In the middle of the joyful moment, Buboy (Enzo Pelojero) sneaks out of the gymnasium to stare at the night sky and talk to Starla (Jana Agoncillo). Buboy picks up a crumpled piece of paper thrown by Dexter (Joem Bascon). The note instructs the young boy to save Starla in the woods; and to keep his mouth shut.
While Dexter is forcibly taking Buboy with him, Boyong (Janus del Prado) passes by and tries to block the abduction. However, Boyong’s attempt only puts his life in danger when Dexter shots him without a warning. Dexter then makes use of Boyong’s tricycle to bring Buboy in the forest.
Mang Greggy (Joel Torre) starts to notice Buboy’s disappearance. He and the other residents begin their search until they find Boyong lying helpless on the ground. Lolita (Anna Luna) is deeply worried while their other friends help her bring Boyong in the hospital.
Meanwhile, in the forest, Dexter threatens Starla and Buboy of killing the both of them if he fails to get his wish. He demands the baby star to fill his bank account with overflowing wealth in exchange of Buboy’s life.
Buboy begs Starla not to risk her final trial wish for Dexter’s evil desires as doing so would lead to her death. But Starla is evidently torn and scared for Buboy’s safety as well.
Following the source of light in the forest, Mang Greggy and Teresa locate Buboy and Starla. For the first time, they witness Starla in a celestial form. But they still have come too late. Starla has already made up her mind and grants Dexter’s wish. The baby star turns black and dies. Buboy holds Starla in his hands while weeping and calls Lola Tala (Charo Santos-Concio) for help.
Mang Greggy comforts a grieving Buboy while Teresa chases Dexter. The two lawyers engage in a violent physical clash until Dexter gets the upper hand against Teresa and is just a blink away from finishing her off. Fortunately, Doc Philip (Raymart Santiago) appears just in time and saves Teresa. Almeda also arrives to run after a fleeing Dexter.
At the Wishing Star Academy, Lola Tala frets as the nebula turns dark, an indication that Starla used her last trial wish to grant an evil desire. Will this be the end of Starla’s life?