Though fascinated by love stories and fairy tales, Carmina (Nadine Lustre) takes great precaution when it comes to romance after witnessing her mother’s pain since her father left them. However, Carmina’s defenses begin to crumble when Yong (James Reid), a young showbiz personality and her longtime crush, befriends and eventually courts her. Fearing an unhappy ending, Carmina asks for a series of signs that would prove that Yong is indeed her Mr. Right. While asking for signs proves to be beneficial for her, Carmina soon realizes that love is not a matter of chance but a conscious choice.